You have seen the pitch. Rents are climbing, rates will come down eventually, so buy a rental now and let the tenant pay your mortgage. It is a good story. The problem is that the math behind it broke somewhere around 2022, and it has not come back.
We already pull Zillow's typical home value and observed rent for every US metro Zillow tracks to power our paycheck map and the PCS map. So we turned the same data on a single question: at today's mortgage rate, in how many American metros does the rent on a typical home actually cover the mortgage? The answer now spans more than 700 metros across all 50 states. You can drag the sliders yourself on the live map. Here is what it says right now.
Put 25% down at today's roughly 7.4% rate. Out of 724 metros, the rent on the typical home covers the full mortgage payment, principal, interest, taxes, and insurance, in 101 of them. That sounds like a lot until you remember that is before you spend a single dollar operating the property.
Set aside a realistic share of the rent for vacancy, maintenance, and management, and the number of metros where a typical rental actually clears its real costs at 25% down falls to eleven. Eleven, out of more than seven hundred.
| 0% down | 15 gross · 0 after costs |
| 20% down | 71 gross · 8 after costs |
| 25% down | 101 gross · 11 after costs |
| 40% down | 250 gross · 54 after costs |
| 50% down | 407 gross · 119 after costs |
You have to put 40% or more down before even a few dozen markets cover their real costs, and at that point you are no longer leveraging the tenant's rent so much as parking a large amount of cash for a thin return.
Here are the markets where a typical rental actually nets positive at 25% down. Look at the home values.
| Metro | Value | Rent | Net after costs | Gross yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indiana, PA | $171,749 | $1,867 | +$218 | 13.0% |
| Meridian, MS | $115,904 | $1,228 | +$195 | 12.7% |
| Big Spring, TX | $138,804 | $1,506 | +$157 | 13.0% |
| Ozark, AL | $161,369 | $1,479 | +$149 | 11.0% |
| Kingsville, TX | $141,002 | $1,447 | +$97 | 12.3% |
| Pine Bluff, AR | $97,258 | $844 | +$37 | 10.4% |
Every one of them is a small, inexpensive market, most with a typical home under $150,000 and rent yields north of 10%. These are not the places people relocate to for a job or a school district. They are where the math works precisely because almost no one is bidding the price up. That is the honest shape of rental cash flow in 2026: it survives in the corners of the country that the relocation market forgot, and almost nowhere people actually want to move.
Colorado Springs is not a cash-flow market at today's rate, and it is honest to say so. The typical home runs about $928 a month short of covering its mortgage at 25% down on asking rent, and about $1,363 short once you count operating costs. Denver is deeper underwater, near $1,444 gross and $1,915 after costs. Austin, Phoenix, Miami, and every other metro people actually move to tell the same story.
That does not make buying here a mistake. It means the case for owning a home in Colorado Springs rests on the things that have actually built wealth in this market, appreciation and amortization over time, not on the rent covering the note from day one. We track that long-run appreciation by zip on the best zip codes page, and the rent side on the live rent tracker. A buyer who understands that is far better protected than one who was sold a cash-flow story the numbers never supported.
None of this is because rents fell. Rents are near record highs. It is because the mortgage on the same home roughly doubled. A home that penciled at a 3% rate does not pencil at 7.4%, even if the rent went up, because the payment is far more sensitive to the rate than to the rent. It is the same force that cut local sales velocity by about a third, which we walk through on the market velocity page, and the same demand curve behind the rate impact tool. Rates move the market. Right now they have moved rental math out of reach almost everywhere.
When rates come down, this map turns greener, and it will do so from the bottom up, the cheaper markets first, which is exactly where the handful of green dots already sit. That is worth watching for. But today, if someone shows you a rental and tells you the rent covers the mortgage, ask to see the payment, the taxes, the insurance, and a real allowance for vacancy and repairs. In most of the country, and here at home, the honest number is still red.
Open the live map and set your own down payment and rate. It covers more than 700 metros across all 50 states and updates with the market.
Get the next data drop by email
Original Colorado Springs market numbers you will not find anywhere else. No spam, just the data.
Have questions about the market?
Get personalized guidance from Rob Thompson.
Get daily email alerts when new homes matching your criteria hit the market.
Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.
No spam, just houses.
Get an accurate homeowner's insurance estimate from Patrick Murakami at Main Street Insurance - no obligation.
Get connected with a trusted local lender for pre-approval, rate quotes, or financing questions - no obligation.