Est. payment
$3,245/mo
9350 Bethpage Road
MLS #: 7699625
Message Rob Save

9350 Bethpage Road, Peyton

Single Family in 80831

List Price
$409,900
Est. monthly payment* $3,245/mo
0% down at today's 7.40% rate, including taxes, insurance. Adjust the scenario below.
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
Year Built: 2004
Days on Market: 0
Taxes: $1,886/yr
Insurance: $3,000/yr est.
Listed By: Muldoon Associates Inc

Estimated Monthly Cost Breakdown*

Mortgage (7.4% / 30yr) Contact a Lender → $2,838.06
Property Taxes $157.20
Insurance Get Quote → $250.00
Total Est. Monthly* $3,245.26
Adjust Your Scenario
Rate defaults to the latest reported 30-year average. Taxes, insurance, and HOA are held fixed.
Own a home nearby? See what it's worth with live MLS + assessor comps. Check My Home's Value →

Market Context - 80831 (Falcon & Woodmen Hills)

Avg Days on Market: 62 ▼ This listing: 0
Avg Close Price: $574,027
Avg CPOLP: 94.9%
Median CPOLP: 95.8%
Active Listings: 276
Closed (30 days): 38

CPOLP = Close Price to Original List Price. Above 100% means sellers are getting more than asking. Based on closed sales in 80831 over the last 30 days.

County Assessor Data

Assessor Market Value: $392,969
Last Sale Price: $270,000
Last Sale Date: Aug 14, 2018
Lot Size: 0.16 acres
Finished SqFt: 1,681
Basement: 364 sqft (299 finished)

Source: El Paso County Assessor. Parcel 4231114006. Assessor values may differ from market value.

Hail Risk - 80831

Moderate
Events (5 years): 13
Largest Stone: 2.0"
Avg Stone Size: 1.15"
Most Recent: Jul 06, 2025

Source: NOAA Storm Events Database. Hail events in this zip code over the past 5 years. Consider roof age and insurance implications.

Building Permits

6 records
May 2025 A/C Coil & Condensing Unit Installation $1,000 Finaled #P85625
Apr 2023 Basement Finish $575 Finaled #O59631
Sep 2022 Furnace Replacement $5,370 Finaled #O31305
Apr 2019 A/C Condensing Unit Replacement $500 Finaled #M22760
Jul 2018 Water Heater Replacement $1,150 Finaled #L65051
Showing 5 of 6 permits Provided as a courtesy - verify at pprbd.org

Recent Comparable Sales (30 Days)

10635 Ross Lake Drive
4 bed / 4 bath · 81 DOM · Closed Nov 06
Listed: $483,000
$410,000
84.9% CPOLP
12726 Winding Glen Lane
3 bed / 3 bath · 31 DOM · Closed Nov 02
Listed: $430,000
$410,000
95.3% CPOLP
11077 Avena Road
3 bed / 3 bath · 10 DOM · Closed Oct 23
Listed: $399,999
$406,600
101.7% CPOLP
12644 Catch Pen Road
4 bed / 4 bath · 6 DOM · Closed Nov 13
Listed: $399,900
$404,900
101.3% CPOLP
12206 Sleeping Bear Road
3 bed / 3 bath · 87 DOM · Closed Nov 12
Listed: $430,000
$392,000
91.2% CPOLP

Based on closed sales in the last 30 days with similar price range and location.

Click here for full details on PPAR →

Call Rob Message Rob Get Alerts for 80831 Save

More Homes in 80831

Price Drop - $70,990 off
13219 Valley Peak Drive
MLS #: 4388302 More Details →
13219 Valley Peak Drive, Peyton
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80831
Beds/Baths: 3/2
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $480,990 $410,000
DOM: 245
Taxes: $3,944/yr
Year Built: 2025
Listed By: Kerrie Ann Young
List Price $410,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,417.42
13674 Nederland Drive
MLS #: 3643205 More Details →
13674 Nederland Drive, Peyton
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80831
Beds/Baths: 3/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $407,800
DOM: 0
Taxes: $1/yr
Year Built: 2026
Listed By: New Home Star LLC
List Price $407,800
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,073.61
Price Drop - $17,500 off
12633 Pine Valley Circle
MLS #: 4018532 More Details →
12633 Pine Valley Circle, Peyton
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80831
Beds/Baths: 3/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $432,500 $415,000
DOM: 95
Taxes: $1,699/yr
Year Built: 2003
Listed By: Exp Realty LLC
List Price $415,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,264.95
11530 Farnese Heights
MLS #: 7900890 More Details →
11530 Farnese Heights, Peyton
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80831
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $400,000
DOM: 10
Taxes: $1,825/yr
Year Built: 2017
Listed By: Exp Realty LLC
List Price $400,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,171.59
The real estate listing information and related content displayed on this site is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information and related content is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Pikes Peak REALTOR® Services Corp d/b/a elevateMLS. Estimated monthly cost assumes 7.4% APR, 30-year fixed, $3,000/yr insurance, and actual taxes. This is not an offer to lend.

Send Rob a Message

Get Listing Alerts

Get daily email alerts when new homes matching your criteria hit the market.

Save Your Favorites

Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.

No spam, just houses.

By registering, you consent to receive listing alerts from Rob Thompson, Realtor. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Get a Personalized Insurance Quote

Get an accurate homeowner's insurance estimate from Patrick Murakami at Main Street Insurance - no obligation.

Contact a Lender

Get connected with a trusted local lender for pre-approval, rate quotes, or financing questions - no obligation.